clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

2005 Amateur Draft Thread

New, comments

Draft discussion goes here.  I'll be updating this with picks as they're made.

1st round: Jay Bruce, L-L 6-2 200, West Brook HS, Beaumont, Texas

Scouting report:

Scouting Report: Coming into 2005, Bruce was regarded as a solid third-round prospect but the fifth-best member of a deep Texas high school outfield crop, behind Jordan Danks, Austin Jackson, Kyle Russell and Jarred Bogany. He since has shot past all of them and into the middle of the first round, and he could go as high as seventh overall to the Rockies. It's a rise reminiscent of Jeremy Hermida's in 2002, and Bruce has similar skills to those of the Marlins' top prospect. Scouts also compare Bruce to Larry Walker. Though he has average to plus tools across the board and enough athleticism to play center field, Bruce profiles better in right field. His swing can get a little long at times, but Bruce is a polished high school hitter. He centers the ball well and already understands the importance of using the entire field. He also has the strength and skill to eventually hit 30-plus homers annually in the majors. His average speed is probably his worst tool, but he plays quicker than his stopwatch readings on the bases and in the outfield. He has more than enough arm to handle the move to right field in pro ball. At one point, Bruce's signability was questionable because he committed to Tulane and chose Scott Boras as his adviser. Bruce since has dropped Boras in favor of Matt Sosnick and is expected to sign for slot money.
Not a bad pick, has the potential to be special.

2nd Round: Travis Wood LHP 6-1 170 Bryant HS Alexander, Ark.

What a stupid pick. I can't wait until Dan O'Brien is gone.

From BA:

Lefty with fastball touching 95 seems intent on being a Razorback

So signability issues. Awesome.

Also from BA:

Wood is a long-term project, albeit an intriguing one because there aren't many lefthanders who can reach 95 mph. His fastball sat at 88-91 mph for much of the spring, but he started making more frequent forays into the mid-90s as the draft drew closer. Wood isn't tall, but he generates his velocity with a quick arm and athleticism. Scouts aren't crazy about his delivery, as he throws with a lot of effort and with some recoil. Wood hasn't shown much aptitude for spinning a breaking ball, and his curveball ranges from below-average to decent. For the most part, he just rears back and blows fastballs by inferior competition, so he'll have to make adjustments at the next level. Wood is considered a tough but not impossible sign. If teams decide he can't be steered away from Arkansas, the state may not have a player drafted in the first 10 rounds.

I'd lay money that this kid will be hurt at some point in the next four years, especially if he's really got such a rough delivery. That's ignoring the fact that he's not going to be major league ready for at least four years, and probably more like six years. And the Reds need pitching help ASAP. Way to go DanO!

3rd Round: Zach Ward, RHP. Jr., 6-3 225, Gardner-Webb, Kannapolis, N.C.

A college pitcher, that I'm kind of meh on. Looks to be a future reliever.

From BA:

Scouting Report: Ward was unheralded out of high school and began to emerge as a prospect while pitching in American Legion ball the summer after his freshman year in college. Ward first attracted attention for his slider, but he has since earned attention and outs with two potential plus pitches. His fastball reaches the low 90s with good sink, and his breaking ball has morphed from his high school slider to a power curveball. Add in a show-me change, and Ward has a chance to throw three pitches for strikes from a durable, innings-eating body. He was dominant in the Cape Cod League last summer, striking out 57 in 43 innings, yet failed to dominate the Atlantic Sun Conference this spring. Ward was used heavily (five of his 15 starts were complete games) and at times lacked command of his fastball, leading to 49 walks in 109 innings and 19 wild pitches. He has a short-arm delivery reminiscent of the late Darryl Kile, and some scouts think it will lead to an arm injury unless Ward moves to the bullpen, where he could concentrate on his fastball and curve.

That's it for me, I'll recap the rest of the draft probably tonight after the game. If anyone is feeling enterprising feel free to post a diary on the rest of the picks.