Year-end player awards: Best position player in a minor league role
2011 Minor League Pitcher of the Year Daniel Corcino, in a walk, with 42% of the vote.
Thanks to BK and 'creds for consulting on these ballots. Without their help, I would probably have included Matt Maloney on this list. He OPSed over .800 this year in the minors.
#
Each year, starting this year, this award goes to the Best Boy in the minor leagues who exemplifies the courage it takes to step into the box against guys who throw 90s heat with sometimes terrifyingly erratic control. And to play for a teams that, at first glance at least, seem to be named after a piece of equipment you use in baseball and a cat that has gotten dirty.
Fresh off a round of promotions for the Louisville Bats' bats and only a few months removed from signings of the Robert Stephenson draft, the organization is in much better shape in the hitting department. Luckily, There is No Such Thing as a Pitching Prospect anyway, the counter-thesis to which is: "Yuh-huh there is such thing as a hitting prospect... and why haven't you promoted him already, dingus?"
Note: Dave Sappelt, Zach Cozart and Jeremy Hermida were all likely deserving of a nomination on the merits of their seasons. But I've omitted them both to slim the list a bit and keep it focused on prospects who are still with the organization. Sappelt and Cozart were both at 350 PAs or below in Louisville before their call-ups, while Hermida was 27 in AAA and departed for San Diego at the end of August.
The presenters:
Mike "Archie" Kurtfalanski, guy who saw Devin Mesoraco get his first major league hit in Busch Stadium
Jean Bentwood, Charterite candidate for Cincinnati Gaming Commissioner (alternate)
MIKE
Playoffs! Still can't believe it, man. Wednesday night was INSANE. I woke up in the morning ON the Arch and I said to myself, I said, "This is really weird." So what choice did I have? I slid down it and pretty much died. But it was all worth it 'cuz Pujols' people called my hospital phone and told me, "How did you get our number? Please stop calling us?" And I said, 'I"m calling from a hospital. Is the King there?' And they said, 'A mental hospital? He's on Glenn Beck's yacht, please don't call again ever.' All you calculator-jockeys said, "no way," but I was like "Colby's gone, he was dead weight, now we got Co-Pat and Mark Rhryruuisihirsijzinskcky, and watch out, Super Bowl here comes the RedBirds!"
JEAN
While someone leads you away, I'll introduce those young, up-and-comers who have been knocking covers off balls from Bakersfield to BIllings, Dayton to Zebulon.
MIKE
Oh, yeah. The nominees for Stupidest Human on Eart--
He's led away.
JEAN
Best position player, in a minor league role. Made possible by Cincinnati USA. Cincinnati, USA: It's located in a state called "USA."
Devin Mesoraco
Still 22 when the season began, the Punxsutawney Kid was among the youngest players in the International League. He hit beyond his years and position, showing power in the gaps (2nd in the IL in doubles) while knocking 15 HRs in 499 PAs. The defensive reports behind the plate have been good too. Devin flashed that doubles power in his very first Major League swing on September 3, crushing a double to left off Mitchell Boggs. Despite a disappointing showing in his cup of coffee, we'll gladly throw out 50 PAs for a 23-year-old phenom who was 15th on BA's midseason prospects list (ahead of the likes of Desmond Jennings).
| Team | PA | BA | OBP | SLG | SB |
| Louisville (AAA) | 499 | .289 | .371 | .484 | 1 |
Grandal is yet another First Round "hit" for the Reds. Drafted just last year, he's done nothing but get on base since he's very brief stint in the Arizona League in 2010. This season, he avoided outs 40% of the time and hit for power, rocketing from A+ Bakersfield all the way to AAA Louisville. As Mesoraco's replacement there, he'll be 23 all next season and is a very credible threat at least to match his season, especially given his good contact skills and 13.7% walk rate.
| Team | PA | BA | OBP | SLG | SB |
| Bakersfield (A+) | 251 | .296 | .410 | .510 | 0 |
| Carolina (AA) | 172 | .301 | .360 | .474 | 0 |
| Louisville (AAA) | 18 | .500 | .667 | .667 | 0 |
| TOTALS | 441 | .305 | .401 | .500 | 0 |
Grandal's fellow Havana native and Miami alum was gone bfore Grandal reached Louisville, but along with Mesoraco, they left big shoes behind for the new class. Alonso made 62 appearances in LF out of 92 games played at AAA before his puzzling call-up/benching/3B experiment/un-benching in the majors. Despite the internal wrangling about Alonso's position, he mashed in AAA and the majors this season. The Reds are desperate to find a place for him as his power continues to bloom.
| Team | PA | BA | OBP | SLG | SB |
| Louisville (AAA) | 409 | .296 | .374 | .486 | 6 |
Ronald Torreyes hails from Venezuela and his name is kind of like a Spanglish portmanteau word for "Bull Eyes." He certainly had the bull eyes this season, as anyone who's a regular Farmer's Only Reader will know. Torreyes started the year in extended spring training, but joined the Dragons in June as one of the youngest players in the Midwest League. Over the remainder of his season prospect mongers thrilled to the 18-year-old second baseman's microscopic 6% K-rate.
| Team | PA | BA | OBP | SLG | SB |
| Dayton (A) | 306 | .356 | .398 | .484 | 12 |
Soto made his name this year by becoming the first Reds' farmhand to hit 30 HRs since Adam Dunn (2001). The 22-year-old's best-in-class power earned him a late season promotion to Louisville, where he'll likely have a chance to work on his discipline at the plate next season.
| Team | PA | BA | OBP | SLG | SB |
| Carolina (AA) | 414 | .272 | .329 | .576 | 0 |
| Louisville (AAA) | 18 | .412 | .444 | .588 | 0 |
| TOTALS: | 432 | .278 | .333 | .576 | 0 |
As far as I can tell, NOT related to the author or the shampoo. But, if you'll allow me to make a very tortured connection between all three, Vidal "cleaned up" and "wrote the book" at Dayton. Vidal is a 2010 8th round draft pick and a quick study. His stock has steadily risen over 1.5 pro seasons between '10 and '11. He was 21 this season and spent all of it playing 3B, hitting for power and getting on base for the Dragons.
| Team | PA | BA | OBP | SLG | SB |
| Dayton (A) | 514 | .280 | .350 | .498 | 3 |
25 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
seeing as he put up over a .400 obp across 3 levels
with plus power, as a switch hitter, at a premium position, in the shadow of the “best” catching prospect in the minors in his first season in pro ball…I vote Jazzman.
Tequila and pancakes, anyone?
by Kevin Mitchell is Batman on Oct 3, 2011 8:40 AM EDT via mobile reply actions
I didn't expect to pick Grandal
but after seeing that season – even if it’s inflated by Bakersfield, 3 levels ain’t nothing to sneeze at and neither is a .400 OBP.
"You said 'walks' twice."
"I like walks."
gotta go with Mez

If only because he’s got eyes as scary as the Soulsucker’s.
All Things Bubba: Because how can you not love a baseball player named Bubba?
Golem.... Golem...
You had me at meat tornado. ~ Ron Swanson
by BigBabyBruce on Oct 3, 2011 10:24 AM EDT up reply actions
I was reading something last night, I can't remember what
but it referred to a “chocolate golem” which made me wish so hard that Mesoraco was black.
It’s an impressive class. Everyone up to and including young Torrojos is impressive.
"You said 'walks' twice."
"I like walks."
For some reason when I've seen him lately the words "Big Baby" have popped into my head.
I realize that Glen Davis has taken that nickname already, but it’s something to keep an eye on moving forward.
by Cuetotally Amazing on Oct 3, 2011 11:37 AM EDT up reply actions
This is an extremely difficult choice
I am highly tempted to go with Bull Eyes because of my rationally irrational love for him. That said, you can’t really go wrong. I go with Grandal.
expectations are premeditated resentments - cheshirecat
Grandal is defensible
But I still think level matters, a lot.
Not only were the bulk of Grandal’s numbers gotten in A ball, they were gotten in the most hitter friendly environment in baseball.
Mesoraco is only 5 months older but got his great numbers all at AAA, which also happens to be a slight pitcher’s league.
Also, Meso’s defense is better. He’s the clear choice.
It feels so nice to be back to normal
valid points.
But I’ve made my claim that Grandal will be better than Mesoraco in the big leagues for precisely the reasons he was successful this year: high OBP, switch hitter, gap to gap power.
I’ve made my bed, so now I must sleep in it. 5 year data-set avatar bet, ‘credsy? I’m not jch, so you’ve at least got a puncher’s chance of winning this one!
Tequila and pancakes, anyone?
by Kevin Mitchell is Batman on Oct 3, 2011 1:49 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Judging by the tone of the piece
I had figured this was based purely on hitting, but if the entire package matters, then I think you gotta go Meso or Grandal. Meso is a good choice for sure.
expectations are premeditated resentments - cheshirecat
No Denis Phipps nomination?
Slgihtly older…. and very reliant on an insane BABIP, but the numbers warrant at least being in the discussion don’t they?
He was on my shortlist
but I wanted to keep it at about 6 or below. I probably could have bumped Vidal for him. Unfairly or not, I docked Phipps for having 338 of his 511 PAs this season a 25/26 year old in double-A.
We’ll be doing an honorable mentions section. He and Hermida definitely deserve mention for how well they hit in the Reds’ system.
Mgr., Red Reporter
"Every office I've been in, there has been a guy with weird scars that he needs to explain to you—'it was one of those old Xerox machines, with a lot of razors in it'... or a pale person with a novel of supernatural erotica that keeps getting left on the printer. Major League lineups need those guys, too." - David Roth
by RijoSaboCaseyWKRP on Oct 3, 2011 2:46 PM EDT up reply actions
Vidal is a way way better prospect that Phipps
I think you made the right call
expectations are premeditated resentments - cheshirecat
I think he played well enough
to at least earn a roster spot before the Rule 5 draft this year.
All Things Bubba: Because how can you not love a baseball player named Bubba?
I wouldn't have added him
But I get why some would. Really though, his skillset didn’t seem to improve much from last year. Walk rate and strikeout rate were right in line with the past. His power was up slightly, but he still didn’t hit for much power. The key difference was his BABIP being about 50% higher for the entire season that you should expect it to ever be again.
I think you just answered your own question why he shouldn't be hitter of the year
For me, it’s more than numbers in the minors, and a 26 year old suddenly tearing up AA ball doesn’t really warrant much praise, IMO.
It feels so nice to be back to normal
I mean before December
I assume the Reds will be making some changes in the roster before the Rule 5 draft.
Phipps might turn out to be a flash in the pan. His 1.004 OPS in Louisville is probably not sustainable. But he’s a good defender, so even if his bat cools off a bit, he’s worth something. I’d add him to the roster and cut Negron or Valaika (who will probably not be taken in Rule 5).
All Things Bubba: Because how can you not love a baseball player named Bubba?
btw, whats the PA threshold to still be considered a rookie? 100?
If so, I bet Yonder was held back because the Reds want him to win ROY in 2012. If he can outplay Volquez, of course.
Tequila and pancakes, anyone?
by Kevin Mitchell is Batman on Oct 3, 2011 1:47 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
Or more than 45 days on the active roster during the 25-man roster period (IOW, not September)
I don’t think Yonder was up early enough to get 45 days on the roster before September, and he’s also only at 127 PAs, so he still has rookie eligibility, I think.
Not that that has anything to do with Dusty’s ridiculous handling of him, but if he’s on the Reds roster next year, that’ll be kind of fun to root for.
It feels so nice to be back to normal
yeah, my comment was part lame sarcasm and part lame attempt at an Edinson for ROY joke.
Seriously though, if he gets 480 PAs as LF, DH, and spot 1B, I think he’s got a damn solid chance to win that award.
Tequila and pancakes, anyone?
by Kevin Mitchell is Batman on Oct 3, 2011 6:53 PM EDT up reply actions






























