I am getting married in about a week and need to put together a gift for my groomsmen and ushers.  Everyone is a Buckeye alum or fan, so I'm getting a nice OSU bucket and beer mug.  I also want to throw 3 good beers and possibly a cigar.  I want a good variety of beers that most people will enjoy that are not ridiculously expensive (i.e. no belgian abbey beers).  So, I figure this is as good a place as any to do a little beer polling. 

List just 1 beer per reply and your rating (1 to 10) of that beer.  If you have had a beer someone else has recommended and want to add your rating, just reply to that string.  Same process for cigars (if I do cigars, I'm looking to be especially budget-conscious on these, but I'd rather not give cigars at all than give crappy cigars).

I appreciate any help people can provide!  Thanks!!!